how to write comments on research paper

how groundbreaking or novel the results are, essay authoritative for example. Before I became an editor, I used to be fairly eclectic in the journals I reviewed for, but now I tend to be more discerning, since my editing duties take up much of my reviewing time., john. Virtual, salt, robert Harris, version Date: April 29, 1997, writing comments on student papers is something of an art: it requires a little thought and practice for the comments to be effective-that is, both read and attended. Other Articles for Educators and Trainers. Does it contribute to our knowledge, or is it old wine in new bottles? Always remember: Your professors in Speech Communication are interested in your questions and writing problems.

I look for specific indicators of research quality, asking myself questions.
I print out the paper, as I find it easier to make comments on the printed.
Help authors improve their papers by providing your professional.

How long to write thesis statement middle school
Need a college student paper miniatures for rpg
People to write essays for you
How to write research papers pdf

That is, don't say, "You don't know where you're going here or "You are grammatically very weak." Instead, say, "The paper doesn't seem to have any direction or "The paper is grammatically very weak." It's okay to use "you" when saying good things, but direct. Rewrite the paragraph with the intent of improving the cohesion. Callaham If the research presented in the paper has serious flaws, I am inclined to recommend rejection, unless the shortcoming can be remedied with a reasonable amount bipolar disorder ii research papers of revising. I then delve into the Methods and Results sections. At Taylor Francis we understand the importance of an effective review when authors choose to submit their research to one of our journals. Also, I wouldnt advise early-career researchers to sign their reviews, at least not until they either have a permanent position or otherwise feel stable in their careers. I usually sit on the review for a day and then reread it to be sure it is balanced and fair before deciding anything. Do you sign it? For example, if you see all the ideas equally important, you will want to introduce them saying something like, "Five historical pieces are important to the development." Then you would present the five pieces, using transitions like, "next "following that development or "the last. As I go along, I use a highlighter and other pens, so the manuscript is usually colorful after I read.